Skip to Content

Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray

Here we are with another really great paint color review! Today we will be discussing the gorgeous color of Boothbay Gray by Benjamin Moore. This color is stunning and I really don’t know why we aren’t talking about it more!

Benjamin Moore has some of the most gorgeous paint colors. I wish I could use them all! My home has been going through a paint transformation this past year and Boothbay Gray was on the short list of colors to use.

I absolutely love the blue-gray side of the spectrum. My home is painted in different shades of them, from almost white to smokey blue. This color is one that would fit right in at my house! I am still trying to think of a place I can use it…

A paint can and paintbrush on a light wood surface.

*This post contains affiliate links. For more details see my full disclosure.

Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray Stats

Every color from every manufacturer is unique. Here are some of the stats for Boothbay Gray:

  • Part of the Historical Collection
  • Hue Family is blue-green
  • Hex code – #aab2b0
  • 66.67% red
  • 69.8% green
  • 69.02% blue

Here is What Benjamin Moore says about this color:

A fresh, steely gray with hints of blue.

Benjamin Moore

What is Boothbay Gray’s LRV?

LRV stands for light reflective value. It is a scale from 0-100 that measures the amount of light a paint color reflects. Zero being the darkest black and 100 being the brightest white.

Boothbay Gray’s LRV is 43.16 which makes it a mid-toned color. Not bright but not dark, somewhere in the middle.

What are the undertones of Boothbay Gray?

This is one of those colors that is greatly impacted by lighting. In some cases it can look steely gray, in others it can look blue or green.

Boothbay Gray is gray with blue undertones and a touch of green.

Is Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray warm or cool?

Because of the blue in the undertones, Boothbay Gray is considered a cool-toned gray paint color.

When paired with other cool-toned colors the blue really comes out in this color. As I mentioned before warmer tones tend to make this color look more neutral.

If you are going for a more modern look or love a coastal theme then this color should be on your list of paint colors to choose from.

How Does Light Affect Boothbay Gray?

As I mentioned before, light can really affect the look of this color. Here are the basics of natural light:

  • North-facing rooms have a light that tends to be a little cooler in nature and will come off slightly blue. Light colors will be a bit more muted or washed out while darker colors will be stunning.
  • East-facing rooms will have brighter light in the morning and less in the evenings. The evening light will be a bit cooler. In the morning with sunrise, the bright sun will be warm. Warm color palettes are great for these spaces because they will help balance the cool feel of the evenings.
  • South-facing rooms have consistent warm light throughout the day. The light really shows off the colors, dark will be very bright, and light colors will shine. Both warm and cool color palettes look good in a south-facing room.
  • West-facing rooms have warm light in the evening and cooler light in the morning. Basically, it’s the opposite of east-facing.

What does this mean for Boothbay Gray? If you have a north facing room the blue undertones are really going to show.

Otherwise you will primarily see a gray. But just to be safe you should always get a sample and look at it through different times of the day for a couple of days.

How to know if a paint color is right for you?

The best way to judge if a color is good for you then you will want to put a swatch on the wall and look at it over a few days. Look at it in different lights and decide if you really like it.

You can do this by getting a sample from the paint store and using a brush to put it up on the walls, but then you are left with a can that you can’t do anything with. Those samples are used with poor-quality paint and aren’t meant for use on your walls permanently.

I recommend going with Samplize. They are a company that will send you a 12X12 peel-and-stick swatch of a paint color that you can stick to the wall. When you are done just peel it off and throw it away.

It’s easy and much less messy!

Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray Whole Home Color Palette

Get this free whole home color palette for Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray and you will also be part of the At Lane and High Community! You will receive weekly newsletters on new posts and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Where to Use Boothbay Gray

You can use this color anywhere in your home. Since it is cool toned it is more commonly used in areas that you are trying to get a more relaxed feeling in (think bedrooms or bathrooms).

I like to be calm in every room so I think it would be appropriate anywhere! But here are some favorites:

  • bedrooms
  • bathrooms
  • nursery
  • office
  • family room
  • accent walls
  • kitchen cabinets and bathroom vanity
  • exterior

Boothbay Gray in a Bedroom

This bedroom from Chris Loves Julia is absolutely gorgeous. I love how they paired the paint color on the wall, which is cool-toned, with the warmer tones in the curtains, bedding, and rug.

Although Boothbay gray is a mid-toned paint color you can see in this room it looks very light and bright. That is due to the amount of natural light coming in the windows. It really makes the color much lighter.

Boothbay Gray on Doors

This is a great color to use on doors and cabinets. 11 Magnolia Lane used it here on the back of the door, loved it so much they used it in their laundry room too!

I love how the color pops next to the crisp whites but it also goes really well with the dark hardwood floors.

Boothbay Gray in an Office

A set of shelves with lots of accessories and framed photos.
Source: Jessie Barnes Barnhardt

This office shines because of Boothbay Gray. It adds an design element that is a great backdrop for accessories but also can hold it’s own.

Here you can see how nicely it looks behind the shelves full of beautiful accessories. It even looks great on the ceiling!

Boothbay Gray in a family room

A family roomw ith a dark gray stone fireplace, white mantel and Boothbay Gray on the walls.
Source: DecorPad

This paint color shines on the walls of this family room! It looks great next to the dark stone of the fireplace as well with the natural fibers of the jute rug!

I love the way it looks next to the crisp white trim too.

Boothbay Gray on the Exterior

A cape cod style home with white siding, white trim and boothbay gray on the door and shutters.
Source: Elegant Painting

I love this gorgeous home! Boothbay Gray was used on the front door and shutters. It looks so good paired with the other colors of the house, which are warm-toned.

The siding is Sherwin Williams Alabaster and the trim is Sherwin Williams Pure White.

Boothbay Gray Accent Wall

This gorgeous nursery from Design Loves Detail uses Boothbay Gray as an accent wall. This is a great idea. It looks so nice with the warm wood tones and the light-colored hardwood floors.

As you can see, Boothbay Gray is a great paint color and can be used in any room, interior or exterior. Now, where would you use this color? I am considering it for the inside of my front door. I just love that look!

Boothbay Gray on cabinetry

A kitchen with white cabinets along the walls and Boothbay Gray on the island.
Source: Jenna Kate at Home

I love the look of having an island a different color than the perimeter cabinets! Boothbay Gray looks stunning on cabinets and I think using the white on the perimeter is a great juxtaposition to this cool gray color.

You can really see how well Boothbay Gray works with the medium toned hardwood floors. It also looks amazing with gold hardware!

What colors look good with Boothbay Gray?

Depending on the type of look you are going for this color can swing more blue or stay neutral gray. You can pair it with other pastel colors to have a more beach house feel or go with warmer tones for a neutral, monochromatic look.

I like to pair it with darker grays, and lighter ones. Different blue colors look really good with Boothbay Gray as well.

What is the best trim color to go with Boothbay Gray?

Trim colors are traditionally white but not all whites are created equally! I like to pair Boothbay with whites that are on the cooler side or close to being a true white.

Here are my favorites:

These all look really beautiful next to Boothbay Gray.

What You Need to Know if Painting on Your Own

If you are thinking about painting a room on your own then good for you! This is one of the easiest things you can do yourself and you will get so much satisfaction out of it. Just make sure you have the right supplies.

You need a good quality paintbrush and roller cover. This is the most important thing! If you don’t use high quality the finish will not be to your liking.

Here are some other posts to help you with your DIY paint project that you should check out before you get started:

Color Comparisons

Boothbay Gray vs Coventry Gray

A side by side of Boothbay Gray and Coventry Gray

I love both of these colors and as you can see they are very similar.

  • Boothbay Gray is a bit darker than Coventry Gray
  • Boothbay Gray has an LRV of 43.26
  • Coventry Gray has an LRV of 48.18
  • Both are cool blue-gray paint colors
  • Coventry Gray is more neutral
  • Boothbay Gray has more blue in it

Get a sample of Coventry Gray from Samplize!

Boothbay Gray vs Smoke

A side by side of Boothbay Gray and Smoke

Both Boothbay Gray and Smoke are from Benjamin Moore and they are pretty different.

  • Smoke is much lighter than Boothbay Gray
  • Boothbay Gray has an LRV of 43.26
  • Smoke has an LRV of 56.39
  • Smoke has blue undertones
  • Boothbay Gray has blue and green undertones

Get a sample of Smoke from Samplize!

Boothbay Gray vs Sherwin Williams Mineral Deposit

a side by side of Boothbay Gray and mineral deposit.

These two are very similar in many ways.

  • Mineral Deposit has an LRV of 43
  • Boothbay Gray has an LRV of 43.26
  • These colors are virtually the same brightness
  • Both have the same blue and green undertones
  • Mineral Deposit has less of the blue green than Boothbay Gray does making it a little more neutral

Get a sample of Mineral Deposit from Samplize!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Sherwin Williams equivalent to Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray?

There is no exact equivalent between paint manufacturers, there are however similar colors. When it comes to Boothbay Gray the closest Sherwin Williams color is Mineral Deposit.

Is Boothbay Gray a good exterior paint color?

It’s a fabulous exterior paint color. It’s famous for doors and shutter colors but can be used on the whole exterior if you want to. Go for it!

Is Boothbay Gray green or blue?

It’s kind of both green and blue because they are used in creating the color. More blue than green but ultimately Boothbay Gray is a gray paint color.


We went over a lot of information here today on this gorgeous color called Boothbay Gray from Benjamin Moore. Let us do a quick summary:

  • From the Historical Collection
  • LRV of 43.26
  • Mid-toned paint color
  • Has blue and green undertones
  • Is a cool gray paint color
  • Pairs really well with other cool colors
  • Looks best with white trim
  • Very calming
  • Often used in bedrooms and bathrooms
  • Closest Sherwin Williams color is Mineral Deposit

Other Gray Paint Color posts:

A view of the top of a paint can with text overlay, pin for Pinterest.

As a licensed Real Estate Agent and an avid home decorator, I strive to give my clients the very best I can when it comes to staging, selling, and decorating their homes. I have lots of experience with paint color choices and love to DIY my home so I can have everything just the way I want it. I share my ideas and projects with the world in the hopes that I can help others have their homes just the way they want as well.

Sharing is caring!

I accept the Privacy Policy

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.